| Name | Title | Vicinage | County | Rate this Judge | Rating | # of Ratings |
| Hon. Alvaro Iglesias | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 6 | Hudson |  | | 0 |
| Hon. Dorothy Incaravito-Garravbrant | Judge | Vicinage 1 | Atlantic | | | 0 |
| Hon. Paul Innes | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 7 | Mercer | | 4.2 | 5 |
| Hon. David Ironson | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 10 | Morris | | 5.1 | 10 |
| Hon. Joseph Isabella | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 6 | Hudson | | 2.1 | 2 |
| Hon. Thomas Isenhour | Judge | Vicinage 12 | Union | | | 0 |
| Hon. James Isman | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 1 | Atlantic | | | 0 |