Hon. Margaret C. Reilly (Nassau) This particular Judge is fair and better than most. She actually makes attorneys complete proper paperwork. However, she likely does not hand out lucrative appointments to those attorneys who can keep her in power because she does not want crime and corruption in her courtroom. I am sure that is why she was given a poor rating. She was not doing enough favors for Joe Cairo, the Republican leader. Thus, Joe Cairo and the Democratic Leader made a deal to have someone else elected as Surrogate. That one person's name will appear on each political party line, Republican, Democrat, Working Parties etc. so that person will get into office. The people no longer have a right to vote in the election process for Judges. The corrupt political parties make the decision regarding who runs for office. Civil Litigation - Private - (3/29/2025 1:37:18 AM)

Hon. Christopher Chin (Bronx) This judge is new in the civil part, clearly inexperienced, and his decisions are based on a misinterpretation of the facts and often a misapplication of the law. I'm in his part often and every attorney I encounter agrees that the part is currently being handled by a judge who is not the brightest. Civil Litigation - Private - (3/28/2025 10:28:18 PM)

Hon. Christopher Chin (Bronx) Judge who does not bother to write opinions based on the evidence presented. He instructs attorneys to write their own orders for his court attorney to type. What a joke! Very lazy, new to the part, rushed part and clearly does not know the law or how to apply it. Incompetent Civil Litigation - Private - (3/28/2025 8:40:30 AM)

Hon. Christopher Chin (Bronx) The worst judge . Will not hear arguments on the record. Lazy. Will ask attorneys to write the decisions for his court attorneys to type. Pro plaintiff judge. Civil Litigation - Private - (3/27/2025 10:05:38 PM)

Hon. Nicholas Palos (New York ) Sadly, this magistrate does not represent the legal community in a positive light. His tone deaf questions and responses to the minorities in his courtroom should be investigated. He does not allow anyone the opportunity to speak or verbalize any concerns. They are not allowed to ask for clarification because he yells at them and reprimands them like children. I believe he needs anger management and should not be a magistrate on the bench. Civil Litigation - Private - (3/27/2025 7:51:30 PM)

Hon. Kathy G. Bergmann (Suffolk) She is the worst. Dumb as a law guardian. Dumber as a Judge. She apparently was awarded this Judgeship by the political parties by taking a child away from a loving mother. It was repayment. Civil Litigation - Private - (3/27/2025 5:07:45 PM)

Hon. Maxine Sonya Broderick (Nassau) She is biased and a racist. She discriminates against those that are white and those with disabilities and appoints the dumbest of the dumb assigned counsel. She is the lackey of Judge Tricia M. Ferrell, a Juge of the same Court. If she/Broderick appears in Ferrell's Courtroom, she/Broderick is there to do her/Ferrell's dirty work. She should be removed from the bench and sued. Criminal Defense Lawyer - (3/27/2025 5:02:31 PM)

Hon. Karen L Moroney (Nassau) She is a disgrace and very biased against those with disabilities and should be removed from the bench immediately and sued. Her husband is an executive at the pharmacy company, Pfizer, and she promoted the covid-19 vaccine. She is friends and neighbors with Madeline Singas, who did favors for her friends, when they were complainants. She/Karen L. Moroney denies Defendants their right to a choice of counsel, the right to represent themselves, and appointed a real idiot as 18b counsel. If a person with a brain disorder needs a "730" exam, she states to do it in jail. I actually saw her put a ankle monitor on a patient, who was confined to a hospital, and developed cellulitis. Her answer was to change the monitor to the other leg, except the person was confined to a hospital, and could not get to the place where it needed to be changed. She has no regard for civil rights. She is a real piece of work and needs to be sued. Criminal Defense Lawyer - (3/27/2025 4:54:28 PM)

Hon. Tricia Ferrell (Nassau) She is the worst of the worst and should be sued civilly and removed from the bench. She should be primaried. She interferes with the choice of counsel and allows the withholding of discovery. She is an abomination. Her secretary Madeline Phelan is even worse. She/Madeline Phelan is a bald face liar Criminal Defense Lawyer - (3/27/2025 4:40:33 PM)

Hon. Caren Loguercio (Suffolk) Judge Caren Loguercio I rate her 0.0 kidnap kids for Cash Black and Brown. Blame mother for neglect when my grandson had medical problems. How in the world a innocent mother be Blame for her baby medical?!!!!! Criminal Defense Lawyer - (3/23/2025 10:15:16 PM)