Logo
Hon. Julie MataSuperior Court JudgeSuperior CourtMaricopa
3.4
Comment # Occupation Rating CommentsDate & Time Actions
134155Other
View Details		Overall terrible experience and will be requesting a new judge. This judge should not be in family law. I don’t have an experience outside of family law with this judge but I can tell you this person is not for the best interest ...Read More10/09/2025 05:00 PMContact reviewer
133952OtherNo RatingThe US~Observer (usobserver.com) is investigating allegations that Judge Julie A. Mata, Maricopa County Superior Court, has relied on material (e.g., social media posts) not formally introduced as evidence in court proceedings, as...Read More09/10/2025 09:59 PMContact reviewer
133639Other
View Details		I once observed Judge Julie A. Mata handle her courtroom with class and dignity in a case that should've been simple, but was made complex by the counsel's litigious filings. Counsel called 911 on a subpoenaed witness because his ...Read More07/17/2025 08:02 PMContact reviewer
133636Other
View Details		Wonderful judge with an honest, informed, and fair perspective. Judge Julie Mata has upped the bar for high-quality and thorough case evaluation. I trust her to look at clear evidence presented and not base her judgments from a bi...Read More07/17/2025 07:14 PMContact reviewer
133442Other
View Details		Judge Mata is fair, respectful, and an overall impartial judge. 06/18/2025 11:33 PMContact reviewer
131523LitigantNo RatingA disgraceful person to ever be in any authority role over other people’s lives. Judge Mata abuses her power and doesn’t look at the situation or what is being presented by both sides she is very quick to not only judge but make i...Read More03/18/2025 09:54 PMContact reviewer
131519Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		[Redacted by Ed.] She rules from the bench and refuses to look at evidence. Suing her in federal court. If you get julie mata... immediately change judge03/18/2025 03:04 PMContact reviewer
130082OtherNo RatingDavid Gingras, an Arizona attorney, appears to be undermining the integrity of the family law justice system through his actions and statements. His behavior, as demonstrated in the post below, raises concerns about ethical standa...Read More12/19/2024 10:42 PMContact reviewer
130058LitigantNo RatingDavid Gingras is a dimwitted ninny. Ignore the reviews below. I pray he gets disbarred soon. I appeared before Judge Mata - With a real attorney, not some douche who thinks he's Connor McGregor when hes actually a sad snot-rag...Read More12/18/2024 05:33 PMContact reviewer
130035Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		***WARNING*** AVOID JUDGE JULIE MATA AT ALL COSTS! Do you have a family law case in front of Judge Julie Mata? If so, you need to IMMEDIATELY exercise your right to have a new judge assigned to your case. Judge Mata is currently...Read More12/16/2024 05:26 PMContact reviewer
129792Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Not a good judge. Started off angry and seemed to have her mind made up. Very short hearing. Requesting a different judge for the next time.11/21/2024 06:58 PMContact reviewer
129776OtherNo RatingHonorable and fair, most negative reviews are very likely from the same scorned individual.11/20/2024 12:56 PMContact reviewer
129437LitigantNo RatingJudge Mata has no business judging anyone to decide what’s best for their children. She seems to decide who she likes before the hearing even begins and be out rude or threaten contempt if she doesn’t like the facts being presente...Read More11/02/2024 09:08 AMContact reviewer
129316Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Sadly, you never know which Judge Mata you're going to get. During one hearing, you may get an attentive and seemingly impartial jurist. In the next, you could get an annoyed, "I'm tired of this case" type of attitude. Once you g...Read More10/22/2024 02:32 PMContact reviewer
128573Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		In a dreary lineup of really slow-witted, portly men, Judge Mata is a shining light. Excellent jurist.09/06/2024 07:39 PMContact reviewer
128324OtherNo RatingAt first Judge Mata seems great. She seems to have a warm, engaging demeanor. However, it doesn't take long to realize that she either doesn't know what she is doing or is just completely lazy. It couldn't be more obvious that she...Read More08/20/2024 12:05 PMContact reviewer
127912OtherNo RatingWow!! The most opinionated, bias and unprofessional judge I have ever had to have contact with. Not interested in hearing out a MOTHER of almost adult in a long drawn out case that had been ongoing for over 5 years. The judges pri...Read More07/22/2024 09:07 AMContact reviewer
127549OtherNo RatingThank you Judge Mata, for being the first jusge to stand up to Laura Owen's fraud! Now the rest will follow suit. Justice has been served.06/29/2024 12:11 PMContact reviewer
127425OtherNo RatingI thought judges were supposed to be un bias and do what is fair? This judge has a major attitude without even hearing much of the case in my situation. I am not sure what has happened to this person in her own life but she is sca...Read More06/21/2024 08:07 PMContact reviewer
127424OtherNo RatingJudge Mata is the best judge I have seen in the courts since 2022 Depp v Heard. During the LO v CE case Judge Mata was patient, fair, reasonable, she had a good knowledge of the law. I would've put LO in jail for always interrupti...Read More06/21/2024 07:52 PMContact reviewer
127417OtherNo RatingThank you, Judge Mata, for seeing through all of the lies and fraudulent documents in your ruling of LO v CE. You're the ONLY judge to do so since 2015! She has weaponized our justice system to abuse and torment at least 4 men wit...Read More06/21/2024 05:10 PMContact reviewer
127414OtherNo RatingI was having internet issues logging into the video court hearing which only took maybe 3 minutes to sort out but when I joined I was Able To hear Judge Mata already talking off record to the opposing sides lawyer. The moment of l...Read More06/21/2024 01:13 PMContact reviewer
127407OtherNo RatingExcellent temperament for the trials she has before her. She is very patient and supportive of the clients in her court room. She paid a lot of attention to all of the evidence that was before her. Very lucky she was presiding ju...Read More06/21/2024 06:31 AMContact reviewer
127400OtherNo RatingThe HONORABLE Judge Mata is exactly that---HONORABLE! She handles her courtroom with grace and patience while maintaining complete control. She considers all evidence and testimony and is very astute. She seeks the truth and swift...Read More06/20/2024 11:09 PMContact reviewer
127398OtherNo RatingHaving followed this case for many, many months, it is refreshing to see a judge that takes in the evidence on both sides and makes a determined and fair decision based on the evidence before her.06/20/2024 10:16 PMContact reviewer
127394OtherNo RatingJudge Mata ruled with lots of thought and care given the evidence. She clearly did the work to accurately rule.06/20/2024 06:05 PMContact reviewer
127371OtherNo RatingJudge Mata ruled fairly and swiftly, given the preponderance of evidence (both real and faked) in this complex case. She ruled fairly and professionally on motions pre-trial and in the courtroom.06/19/2024 06:34 PMContact reviewer
127368OtherNo RatingShes no BS. Found her to be very fair and ask the right questions. She has far more patience than me.06/19/2024 03:35 PMContact reviewer
127367OtherNo RatingShes no BS. Found her to be very fair and ask the right questions. She has far more patience than me.06/19/2024 03:35 PMContact reviewer
125971LitigantNo RatingClearly biased from the start. I had custody of my children for the past several years, year after year, my ex takes me to court with a new lawyer once the mandatory year is up and she can file. Year after year, she was denied, so...Read More03/24/2024 12:02 AMContact reviewer
123320OtherNo RatingShe judges upon her past cases and will threaten punishable contempt of court while ignoring provided proof of the other parties lawyer lying repeatedly in court documents and under oath in hearings. If you are representing yourse...Read More11/05/2023 04:23 PMContact reviewer

© Copyright The Robing Room All Rights Reserved