The Robing Room

Hon. Stephen F. McCarvillePresiding JudgeSuperior CourtPinal

1.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
47891	Other	No Rating	On first meet it was very clear that there would be no fairness for me (Husband). He is very quick to give the woman everything, even when it is very, very demonstrable that ex-wife had no basis for asking for support (I paid for ...Read More	02/22/2017 05:17 PM	Contact reviewer
37754	Other	No Rating	McCarville comes to the bench with strong bias towards mothers. He orders mediation but then completely fails to even read mediation report. He is incredibly reluctant to make a ruling and, instead, wastes litigants' money until ...Read More	09/26/2015 06:10 AM	Contact reviewer
30840	Other	No Rating	Could be one of the dumbest people Ive ever seen. He took my parenting time from me at the temp order. He obviously looked at the wrong case. Ive been around kids my whole life. We had a parenting plan in place. He gave spou...Read More	11/07/2014 05:22 AM	Contact reviewer
29525	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	One-sided! Incompetent! Violates time frames and due process rights. Already chooses a side and does not read, listen, or consider motions, discussions, evidence, etc. Get a new judge! Sorry excuse for a judge!	09/17/2014 10:30 PM	Contact reviewer
29524	Other	No Rating	I would actually give this judge a 0 or -10. He is the most biased judge I've ever seen. He is NOT fair! He is NOT impartial. He can't count to 30, which subsequently lends him to violating litigants' due process. He should be rem...Read More	09/17/2014 10:26 PM	Contact reviewer
27934	Other	No Rating	This Judge is corrupt. He is favors certain Lawyers especially Mathew Ritter. They need to both disbarred. Judge McCarville does not follow the State Statues and makes rulings and doesn't even follow his own rulings.	07/06/2014 04:13 PM	Contact reviewer
25364	Other	No Rating	The other comments on this judge seem to be the norm for this judge.	02/25/2014 03:17 AM	Contact reviewer
25196	Other	No Rating	I was in the final stages of my divorce, and the only things that my ex and I could not agree on were custody of our minor child and alimony payments. I was seeking sole custody, which was denied, even though I showed proof of my ...Read More	02/12/2014 04:25 PM	Contact reviewer
12661	Litigant	No Rating	This Judge does not follow Arizona Revised Statues, nor does he make decisions that are in the best interests of the minor children involved the cases. He does not allow litigants to speak, and does not listen to both sides before...Read More	12/28/2011 10:14 PM	Contact reviewer