Logo
Hon. Polly H. ShamoonJudgeSuperior CourtSan Diego
1.2
Comment # Occupation Rating CommentsDate & Time Actions
127082OtherNo Rating[Redacted by Ed.]She's both a judge and a DA on the bench. She has no respect for the law or my rights. In the course of presiding over my habeas petition under the Racial Justice Act, she has violated court rules, Legislative Int...Read More05/31/2024 09:57 PMContact reviewer
126949OtherNo RatingJust a really bad judge. Does not do her homework and heavily, I mean heavily relies on the DA to give her the facts of the case when the facts are incorrect. She does not like to be corrected and will punish you for doing so. She...Read More05/21/2024 04:11 PMContact reviewer
126938OtherNo RatingI would rate this judge as a 0. Absolutely the worst of the worst and does not even read her police reports to get the right facts of the crime. She just goes by what the DA says and does no leg work herself. How is someone like ...Read More05/20/2024 05:45 PMContact reviewer
120899OtherNo RatingBad Judge all the way around, and everyone knows it - including those who censor this website's content. Polly maintains her public servant courtroom status per the California State Bars unconditional endorsement that discourages ...Read More10/05/2023 07:19 PMContact reviewer
120656OtherNo RatingShe is a horrible biased judge and a worse human being-tries to be superior to all who enter her courtroom-should really be fair from the start. In American we are innocent until proven guilty by a jury of or peers, not by a contr...Read More09/18/2023 10:27 PMContact reviewer
120647OtherNo RatingAlert! This judge has no regard for defendants civil or constitutional rights. She is vicious! Long before my family member has had a trial or sign a deal she has stated exactly what they did and they are guilty. Well judge I am n...Read More09/18/2023 03:39 PMContact reviewer
119384Criminal Defense LawyerNo RatingDuring the last few months we have been dealing with Judge Molly, my wife and I had nothing to say but to thank God for having her residing over our daughter’s case. Judge Molly was not only compassionate and professional in her d...Read More07/12/2023 10:06 AMContact reviewer
116367Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Every lawyer I know ranks her as the Worst Judge in San Diego. So glad they moved her out of the Settlement department. She hates Defendants and wants them locked up as long as possible. She has no heart and doesnt care. She is ru...Read More02/22/2023 08:06 PMContact reviewer
72495OtherNo RatingThis tyrannical fascist psychopath forced me to leave the US permanently to avoid a completely undeserved jail sentence. She doesn't understand a things about the United States Constitution or Bill of Rights, especially the 4th a...Read More07/15/2019 02:27 AMContact reviewer
69905Criminal Defense LawyerNo RatingShe is incompetent and is covering that by accommodating the DA and delivering the max. She is unfair and a disgrace to the judicial system and should be removed. She doesn’t consider the welfare of the society and she sends its k...Read More06/03/2019 03:02 AMContact reviewer
69892OtherNo RatingThis judge is wretched. She treats defendants like a number and scum on her shoe. She has no desire for 'rehabilitation' nor does she look at mitigation packets or review the cases prior to sentencing. She seems generally uniforme...Read More06/02/2019 09:23 AMContact reviewer
55873OtherNo RatingPolly Shamoon is very rude as person and very awful judge. Very bias she is the DA girl. Dose not have any knowledge about the cases she just want to sentence people to the max for DA to be happy. Polly Shamoonis well known at th...Read More05/10/2018 12:48 AMContact reviewer
55621OtherNo RatingJudge Polly Shamoon seems to be coming from a different culture She lacks understanding of the American values. She has no clue about the separation of the judiciary branches. She is incompetent in the law. This is why she adapts ...Read More05/02/2018 10:58 PMContact reviewer
55619OtherNo RatingI was incourt Watching this judge on the bench,this woman has inferiority complex .her behavior is driven by compensation trying to prove something she lacks ,very direspectefull of others,not cultured ,I believe she should do...Read More05/02/2018 10:29 PMContact reviewer
55552Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		I echo what everyone else has said, she is so pro prosecution. It is a shame that the court has continued to assign her year after year to a settlement department what an injustice04/30/2018 11:33 PMContact reviewer
55550OtherNo RatingShe is rude and unfit to be a judge and she is a disgrace to the judicial system. She is biased towards the prosecutor and does not evaluate evidence and testimonies fairly rather she champions the DA. She comes out predetermined ...Read More04/30/2018 10:54 PMContact reviewer
43104Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Only takes into account the DA. Assumes the defendant is guilty from the start.06/02/2016 04:33 PMContact reviewer
37548Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Absolutely the rudest judicial officer on the bench. Totally undermines defense attorneys before their clients and affords little to no respect to the named defendants. Horrible judicial temperament. Unbelievable that she must ...Read More09/14/2015 02:04 PMContact reviewer
36959Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		What an idiotic narcissist! Absolutely in the pocket of the D.A. You're no longer part of the prosecution team genius!!08/17/2015 06:50 PMContact reviewer

© Copyright The Robing Room All Rights Reserved