Logo
Hon. Charles S. TreatJudgeSuperior CourtContra Costa
1.5
Comment # Occupation Rating CommentsDate & Time Actions
132063Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Love Treat when I'm not on the receiving end of him ripping someone's a**. Buyer beware. B.S. Judge Treat at your own risk. Pushing back - especially after he told you were wrong - will earn a juicy take down.04/02/2025 03:01 AMContact reviewer
104000OtherNo RatingThis is a tired lazy judge who seems to care more about getting out of the court room than actually hearing and considering a case. Although hearing a proven case to every letter of the law, he ruled based on his opinion. As with ...Read More04/08/2022 10:31 AMContact reviewer
73213Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		This is a horrible judge. He ignored the clear law and made up non-existing reasons not found in the law when ruling on a simple law and motion matter. He is arrogant and demeaning to counsel.07/26/2019 11:44 AMContact reviewer
69987Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Flat out wrong about the law in ruling on a motion. Based his entire ruling on a one-liner from a case (a citation to another case) that was completely dispelled later in that same Supreme Court opinion. At best, he's not knowledg...Read More06/05/2019 10:46 AMContact reviewer
61151OtherNo RatingThere is a difference between upholding the law and creating the law. This judge doesn't seem to know the difference His decisions have to go to the Appellate Court. Now how is that economy of taxpayers money?10/31/2018 02:51 PMContact reviewer
47729LitigantNo RatingI would give him a zero, if I could. Judge Treat was rude and abrupt, and did not let us present evidence or call witnesses, even though we WON in Small Claims and were appearing before him on appeal. He favors high profile atto...Read More02/14/2017 01:02 PMContact reviewer
44638OtherNo RatingWorst--lots of eye rolling and inability to listen to "the facts". He had is mind made up before the facts were presented, and refused to listen. My case went to the appellate court and his bad ruling was reversed in a landslide...Read More08/06/2016 12:48 AMContact reviewer
41965OtherNo RatingJudge Treat heard our case for 7 years and I can say that he doesn't sweat the small stuff. judge Treat sees through people's smoke screen and gives people a chance to prove themselves. For instance, a mother with a substance abus...Read More04/11/2016 06:00 PMContact reviewer
29337OtherNo RatingDespicable, mean, cruel, one sided, bribed, quite likely to rot in hell. No...definitely will rot in hell.09/08/2014 11:21 PMContact reviewer
26540OtherNo RatingThis judge was appointed by Arnold Schn. and we know what he was about. Judge Treat condones attorneys sleeping with their clients and tries to tap deep wells to get attorneys lots of money. The guy is corrupt through and throug...Read More04/16/2014 09:37 PMContact reviewer
21165Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Absolutely AWFUL. This guy has NO business being a judge in this state.04/21/2013 02:05 PMContact reviewer
18463OtherNo RatingTreat clearly makes his decision prior to entering the courtroom. In my case, an utterly simple procedural situation needing no determination on his part, he simply found an excuse not to rule (a missing document not required in t...Read More11/06/2012 05:59 PMContact reviewer
18227OtherNo RatingHe is the reason why our preschool is shutting down in San Leandro, Heaven Sent Discovery. He doesn't take into factor who this will affect...the teachers, the staff, the parents...and most importantly our kids, who are future.10/25/2012 06:30 PMContact reviewer
17926LitigantNo RatingTreat is an ivory-tower type of Judge. He judges a book by its cover and has little regard for the facts. Judge Treat was just looking to check the box with his family court assignment and has little regard for the people that com...Read More10/11/2012 12:34 AMContact reviewer
17804OtherNo RatingMy first experience in any court situation. Judge Treat ruled in such an unfair and absurd manner. He did not read his court briefs that were filed in the case. His "rationale" for his ruling does not take both sides into accou...Read More10/02/2012 10:58 PMContact reviewer
16469Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Hate hate hate his guts. Ruined my life. He doesn' t seem to BELIEVE in mental disability. Heavily favors super lawyers. Unbalanced...ni justice....a-hole07/27/2012 11:10 PMContact reviewer
14276OtherNo RatingRude misinformed, hostile ignorant, should go get some anger management training. Will never be more than a Family Court judge and does that very poorly. Follows no protocol,process,in dealing with the emotionally charged situatio...Read More03/28/2012 02:48 PMContact reviewer
13430OtherNo RatingJudge Treat is biased against fathers with custody of their children. He didn't enforce his own orders regarding a long term drug addicted/alcoholic mother actually complying with his orders for her to be randomly drug tested, but...Read More02/11/2012 01:53 AMContact reviewer
12985OtherNo RatingI have never had previous experiance with our country's judicial system...Judge Treat has given me a shocking view of why there exists such a feeling of cynisism with regard to how our court system works. This man is utterly insuf...Read More01/19/2012 07:43 PMContact reviewer
12581LitigantNo RatingJudge Treat is simply coasting through his 'term' in FAMILY court. He is passive, and refuses to make any difficult decisions relative to the children, even when he has specific recommendations on what should be done from the Cou...Read More12/17/2011 01:52 AMContact reviewer
12403OtherNo RatingJudge Treat should not be a judge in FAMILY court. He is a procedure judge and cares little for the family before him. He belittles and embarasses counsel and the family member that they represent. He is unfair in all of his judge...Read More11/29/2011 01:34 PMContact reviewer
11620Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Judge Treat is without any doubt the WORST jurist before whom I have ever appeared. He is biased against women. He REFUSES to follow the law and makes it up as he goes along. He threatens counsel with removal from the court roo...Read More08/19/2011 10:50 PMContact reviewer
11614OtherNo RatingJudge Treat clearly makes up his mind about a case before he enters the courtroom. It doesn't matter what you say, he doesn't want to hear it. I thought this is what a trial is for , to present evidence to substanciate what has be...Read More08/19/2011 03:14 AMContact reviewer
11463LitigantNo RatingThis Judge does not listen. He will smugly remark that he should listen more and talk less and then turns around and contradicts himself. He makes up his mind based upon what he thinks is true rather than any concrete evidence. ...Read More07/26/2011 02:47 AMContact reviewer

© Copyright The Robing Room All Rights Reserved