The Robing Room

Hon. Deirdre H. HillJudgeSuperior CourtLos Angeles

1.3

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
128102	Civil Litigation - Private	No Rating	[Redacted by Ed.] She claims in documents dated 2020, (stored outside of my home)which is robbed often, even though I changed the locks 14 times in nine years... and the thief are on cameras. This judge claims I stood before s...Read More	08/07/2024 03:48 PM	Contact reviewer
105486	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	[Redactged by Ed.] She came to the bench late every day one week, and sat there awith her big oversized beach glasses on, sipping a big oversized Slurpeee and is doing her makeup in front of the entire courtroom, while attorneys...Read More	06/08/2022 08:15 PM	Contact reviewer
104444	Criminal Defense Lawyer	No Rating	[Redacted] This lady is worse than what everyone is saying on here, absolutely. She does not even deserve a 1-rating out of 10 if 1 is the worst and 10 is the best. She deserves a zero. She definitely did not read the paperwork su...Read More	04/25/2022 07:18 PM	Contact reviewer
101846	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Judge Hill has no desire to be a Judge and it shows. Literally every tentative ruling she issued she reversed after oral argument. She consistently got snowed and connned by frivolous and nonsensical legal arguments. He lack of...Read More	12/29/2021 01:53 PM	Contact reviewer
66382	Litigant	No Rating	Duty to maintain impartiality is a joke to her. Deirdre is a disgrace. She is Biased. Issues unjust sanctions on discovery motions without reading opposition papers. Inpatient. Doesn’t read … and she truly just makes so much work ...Read More	03/07/2019 12:37 AM	Contact reviewer
51366	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	The worst judge I have ever dealt with at LASC. She is incredibly lazy and refuses to do her job. Will not read papers, overrules herself, and refuses to do anything on the case. She just grants whatever in favor of the defendan...Read More	08/30/2017 05:57 PM	Contact reviewer
47774	Civil Litigation - Private	No Rating	How many of us have to complain and suffer before they realize that she is incompetent and throw her off the bench? She is an idiot.	02/16/2017 12:50 PM	Contact reviewer
47746	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	She is unprepared and has not read the papers and she does not follow the law.	02/15/2017 12:59 PM	Contact reviewer
47745	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	I thought that the other lawyers posting comments here on her might have been exaggerating. However, she really is a bad judge. She does not listen and she is a lazy thinker. I do not believe that my client can get a fair trial...Read More	02/15/2017 12:47 PM	Contact reviewer
46704	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Judge Hill is not fit to wear the robe. She was consistently late, unprepared, and disorganized. I believe that she doesn't read any briefs but relies solely on her law clerk. Her current trial estimate is 4 hours per day of ac...Read More	12/12/2016 01:47 PM	Contact reviewer
41411	Civil Litigation - Private	No Rating	the problem is the bar for bias or prejudice is higher than the incredibly bad rulings she makes. she just makes so much work for the appellate. lets vote her out Over the Hill textbook sociopath. she views her court as daily ente...Read More	03/12/2016 05:20 PM	Contact reviewer
40377	Criminal Defense Lawyer	No Rating	Terrible and angry judge. Ignores the law to achieve her own agenda. Unfortunate for the state that she is a judge.	01/25/2016 06:22 PM	Contact reviewer
28794	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	I agree 100% with the comment CA4658 posted on 12/19/2013. She definitely takes sides and loves to sanction. She clearly does not understand how to read a case or how to apply basic law to the case before her. She makes snap jud...Read More	08/14/2014 10:33 PM	Contact reviewer
24667	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	She takes a side and then is merciless, ruthless, vindictive and punitive against the party she doesn't like. She likes to sanction, and likes to make rulings making sure that the losing party loses and loses big. If she's against...Read More	12/19/2013 04:26 PM	Contact reviewer
16311	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Deidre Hill is an incompetent judge. If she was practicing law, I doubt that she could earn even a fraction of her judicial salary. She can also be extremely vindictive. She will openly refuse to follow black letter law, and does...Read More	07/16/2012 01:28 PM	Contact reviewer
3268	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	I tried a commercial unlawful detainer action in front of her to a jury, to avoid the customary prejudice against defendants so common among U/D judges. She rewrote the CACI Instructions on several critical elements of the cause s...Read More	11/03/2008 12:16 AM	Contact reviewer