The Robing Room

Hon. Dorothy L. ShubinJudgeSuperior CourtLos Angeles

1.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
55678	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	She is one of the worst judges in L.A. County, and fits with all the bad judges especially in Pasadena, and the San Gabriel Valley. She disfavors the underdog, makes her ruling on based on who she views as politically powerful, a...Read More	05/04/2018 05:17 PM	Contact reviewer
44043	Other	No Rating	This is perfect example of one that should NOT be in a position of Judge. Egotistical, bias, and closed minded to any facts or evidence presented before her. Rules based on preconceived opionion rather than facts presented before...Read More	07/01/2016 05:07 PM	Contact reviewer
39840	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Very discouraging the level of bias demonstrated toward criminal defendants. A vain and ego driven woman. Politically motivated, Don't stop here notify the Commission on Judicial Performance. The judiciary at the Pasadena Court...Read More	12/30/2015 10:43 AM	Contact reviewer
37711	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Prosecutor favoring. Hears prosecutors argument and rules accordingly. Oversteps her judicial discretion, basing rulings on what she thinks rather than what the law is. Flips her hair back, rolls her eyes, and always looking at t...Read More	09/24/2015 02:12 PM	Contact reviewer
36811	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Should not be a judge. Needs to be off the bench. Knows nothing about civil lit.	08/09/2015 08:20 PM	Contact reviewer
29275	Other	No Rating	Was unwilling to listen to testimony or previous history of the dependent. Was callous, cold, and easily frustrated. She seemed to want the highest prosecution despite the specifics of the case or the strength if the defendants ar...Read More	09/07/2014 02:31 AM	Contact reviewer
15406	Litigant	No Rating	I had the misfortune to have Shubin hear a simple small claims case in Alhambra Court. After two minutes it was clear that this egomaniac was more interested in ruling on issues other than the facts before her. At every turn she c...Read More	06/10/2012 09:50 PM	Contact reviewer