The Robing Room

Hon. Pamela A DavisCommissionerSuperior CourtAlameda

1.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
135124	Litigant	View Details	Biased and lazy. Made up her mind before hearing the evidence and reviewing the law. Helped the other side instead of staying neutral. Did not feel heard.	02/06/2026 09:31 PM	Contact reviewer
132746	Other	No Rating	Before my hearing, I observed Judge Davis preside over two other small claims cases. In each, I noticed a troubling pattern of behavior: litigants who appeared to be of non-Caucasian background were interrupted more frequently, tr...Read More	05/14/2025 11:28 PM	Contact reviewer
132139	Litigant	No Rating	I have been in front of this commissioner many times. She has ruled on many of my cases against health insurance carriers. SHe is smart , diligent and gets the issues. She does the research and rules fairly ( I dont always win unf...Read More	04/06/2025 02:39 PM	Contact reviewer
130885	Litigant	No Rating	Agree with other comments, this elderly judge (meaning she has difficulty to read and understand and is not qualified based on those her disabilities to be a judge) not even a judge, but commissioner. Not sure how commissioner per...Read More	02/07/2025 12:15 PM	Contact reviewer
128774	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	The worst judge I’ve ever experienced in my 31 years of practicing law. How do you talk about this judge without sounding like it’s all sour grapes… ?The way you do it effectively is to get her decisions reversed. She was sitting...Read More	09/21/2024 05:26 AM	Contact reviewer
126096	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Starting w/ this Reuters article- https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-judges-misconduct/ I rate her Zero..... Judge Pamela A Davies is not a good judge handling the small court claims, when comes to handle co...Read More	04/01/2024 01:41 PM	Contact reviewer
123909	Litigant	No Rating	If this is the same judge that is currently at the Beverly Hills courthouse (as of 12-1-23), she is horrible. I walked into the courtroom and saw a 70 year old woman with horrendous plastic surgery to her face (one too many plasti...Read More	12/01/2023 04:03 PM	Contact reviewer
120852	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	I was this bench officers bailiff at Santa Monica Court when she was in Dept B “Traffic”. Her and her judicial assistant are two terrible and evil people. The Commissioner had me removed from the courtroom because I would not allo...Read More	10/02/2023 02:01 PM	Contact reviewer