The Robing Room

Hon. Brian CaruthJudgeSuperior CourtAlameda

3.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
135494	Other	View Details	Judge Caruth is patient, truly educated about domestic violence issues and can spot an abuser through their lies under oath. He goes to bat for domestic violence victims asking for help and he does just that. Judge Caruth does not...Read More	03/27/2026 02:04 AM	Contact reviewer
135346	Other	View Details	I observed only two cases. judge did not appear to have read case material in advance. judge did not consider court mediator recommendations judge issued a restraining order without any supporting evidence	03/11/2026 09:22 PM	Contact reviewer
135302	Litigant	View Details	Compassionate and fair judge, with a level head on his shoulders. He can see through manipulators and is also willing to reach a fair settlement if needed. Far more empathic judge than most. Follows the letter of the law as well.	03/04/2026 10:32 PM	Contact reviewer
134362	Other	View Details	He is horrible at being a judge I presented him with evidence and he still let the other party off scotch free! Smh…	11/06/2025 06:34 PM	Contact reviewer
132387	Litigant	No Rating	This judge should be removed he just sitting on the bench for a check and railroading people off of false allegation of attempt murder, harassment and child abuse which the other party lied because if this was true why didn't plai...Read More	04/23/2025 09:06 PM	Contact reviewer
131121	Litigant	No Rating	Brian Caruth is far from anyone to call me a judge because he lack so many skills to even hold Honorable Judge Caruth in department 105. The first judge Jones is the evil person who placed the first Stay Way Order who clearly knew...Read More	02/18/2025 12:27 PM	Contact reviewer
130918	Other	No Rating	Everyday this girl harass me and my mother I will post here! So, today we get a notice that the sister has sent certified mail to my mother. The judge decided to give this liar a renewal and that is the ammunition she needed to p...Read More	02/08/2025 05:10 PM	Contact reviewer
130916	Criminal Defense Lawyer	No Rating	This judge is not only dangerous but so green he needs to be trained. It is clear that he is confused and does not read the cases beforehand. I filed for a stay away order in the defendant and the plaintiff lied to get protecti...Read More	02/08/2025 02:15 PM	Contact reviewer
130887	Other	No Rating	Brian Caruth allowed a pathological liar on the loose and the as soon as she got a renewal she damage my mothers car. She keyed it up and down last night due his judgement yesterday. This woman has subjected falsified documents,...Read More	02/07/2025 02:46 PM	Contact reviewer