The Robing Room

Hon. Ami Sheth SagelJudgeSuperior CourtOrange

1.9

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
135542	Other	View Details	She is the worse judge, separate loving mom and 4 years old son. Put him with manslaughter abusive father for over 18 months away from a foster mom. Ami sagel is been picked on the mother mental health slightly depression report ...Read More	04/02/2026 05:35 AM	Contact reviewer
135462	Court Staff	View Details	I've worked in the court for over 10 years and every staff member I speak with agrees that Ami Sagel is the single worst judge in Orange County. Litigants have been holding a DAILY protest right outside of our courthouse for month...Read More	03/24/2026 04:47 PM	Contact reviewer
135420	Other	View Details	My experience with Judge Sagal is as an attorney in adoption proceedings. I found her to be quite knowledgeable in this small sub-area of family law, which many judges are not. She was always extremely pleasant to the participants...Read More	03/19/2026 03:28 AM	Contact reviewer
134950	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Definitely worth the peremptory challenge before trying to litigate your case in this wackos courtroom. Never seen a less qualified judge in all my years of practicing law.	01/17/2026 01:56 AM	Contact reviewer
134098	Other	View Details	Discharge kidnapped. My child is racist against Native Americans and trafficked my child a.k.a. rented my child to me for an hourly rate and I’m a fit parent!	10/02/2025 03:11 AM	Contact reviewer
133038	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	`Just a word of advice to my colleagues based upon my personal experience appearing before Judge Sagel in several family law cases. I've found that Sagel decides almost immediately which litigant she likes, and which litigant she ...Read More	05/19/2025 01:19 PM	Contact reviewer
132703	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Worst judge ever. Committing fraud and covering up fraud. Allowing fraud upon the court to occur in my case. Not reporting crimes being committed and committing crimes herself. Endangering children endangering my child literally w...Read More	05/11/2025 01:41 AM	Contact reviewer
132390	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Truly one of the worst and most incompetent judges ever appointed to the bench. Judge Sagel's temperament often borders on the bizarre, randomly snapping at almost anything, acting as though she's the only adult in the room, often...Read More	04/24/2025 04:59 PM	Contact reviewer
130141	Litigant	No Rating	Our experience with Hon. Ami Sheth Sagel was deeply troubling, and I feel it is important to share our concerns. This judge is not only incompetent but also exhibits a clear bias against men. Her rulings consistently lack impartia...Read More	12/26/2024 05:58 PM	Contact reviewer
129812	Other	No Rating	Absolutely the best Judge if you're representing a female client, especially mothers, but possibly the worst Judge if you're representing a man, especially dads. This rating of 9 only applies for female litigants, where almost eve...Read More	11/23/2024 01:41 PM	Contact reviewer
129779	Other	No Rating	Stay away from this judge. She is brand new to the bench and is actively ruining families. She is strongly aligned with women. She refuses strong evidence and eliminates witnesses supporting the opposition. She is more focused on ...Read More	11/20/2024 02:42 PM	Contact reviewer
129748	Other	No Rating	Terrible. She let her emotions and feelings, felt like she had her mind made up before anything was discussed. It was obvious she favors women. I thought that in family court, the judge is required to do what is best for the child...Read More	11/17/2024 10:05 PM	Contact reviewer
127632	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	One of the worst Family Court judges I have seen over a long career. It is apparent she performed well in Criminal Court, however is not a parent and I believe not married. Should have no business presiding in FC where children ...Read More	07/06/2024 01:23 PM	Contact reviewer