The Robing Room

Hon. Brian S. McCarvilleJudgeSuperior CourtSan Bernardino

3.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
120047	Other	No Rating	As a Civil Rights Leader/Advocate and a Court Observer, on multiple occasions, I have observed this judge been extremely bias against non-represented litigants. He regularly intimidates them in his courtroom; and denies them their...Read More	08/18/2023 04:26 AM	Contact reviewer
118032	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	I was Judge McCarville's Pre Trial and Trial Deputy Public Defender for a number of years. Only have good things to say about him.	05/13/2023 01:54 AM	Contact reviewer
100497	Other	No Rating	CA37989 so obvious	11/10/2021 07:34 PM	Contact reviewer
100495	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Judge McCarville is the most bias judge I have ever encountered. I have been in practice for 15 years and I have never experienced the type of prejudice from a Judge in my life. He doesn't understand complex contract-real estate c...Read More	11/10/2021 07:32 PM	Contact reviewer
77648	Other	No Rating	My 10 year old life time brain injured son unfortunately lost the judge in charge of his case for almost 7 years. Sadly McCarville was available and we got stuck with him at the last minute. He yelled at the father for "reacting"...Read More	10/14/2019 11:35 PM	Contact reviewer
59513	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Judge McCarville will let you try your case. He tries to be even handed, but leans a bit toward local lawyers. I found him to be wise and generally fair. I would recommend you keep him if you draw him as your Judge. You could ...Read More	09/12/2018 12:14 AM	Contact reviewer
58368	Other	No Rating	My case was handled unjustly. Judge, Mccarville prevented my case from going before a jury. He had in his possession statements from both parties and deemed on side hear say without supporting documentation or cross-examinations. ...Read More	08/02/2018 01:26 AM	Contact reviewer