The Robing Room

Hon. Gary NadlerJudgeSuperior CourtSonoma

1.3

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
127043	Litigant	No Rating	Pretend-folksy, unpredictable, unprofessional demeanor. Does not read pleadings, shows up unprepared thinking he can “wing it”. Makes serious mistakes, then becomes flippant. Somehow managed to issue separate, contradictory ruling...Read More	05/28/2024 10:45 PM	Contact reviewer
102216	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Cold hearted. Uninformed. Pompous. Unable to admit when making mistake. Courtroom manner is abominable.	01/17/2022 04:20 PM	Contact reviewer
102215	Litigant	No Rating	The Judge’s behavior was so egregious that his ruling was a proximate cause of my husband’s suicide just hours after Judge’s unfair ruling. He was presented a fact filled case, backed up by very strong evidence. He obviously did ...Read More	01/17/2022 04:16 PM	Contact reviewer
102214	Litigant	No Rating	The Judge’s behavior was so egregious that his ruling was a proximate cause of my husband’s suicide just hours after Judge’s unfair ruling. He was presented a fact filled case, backed up by very strong evidence. He obviously did ...Read More	01/17/2022 04:16 PM	Contact reviewer
44011	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	He's overly impressed with himself without good cause. He is not particularly decisive. He's wrong on the law.	06/29/2016 04:34 PM	Contact reviewer
36892	Civil Litigation - Govt.	View Details	Indecisive. Egotistical. Phony friendly demeanor. Not an intellectual. Does not write intelligible, organized or accurate orders. Doesn't remember facts or law. Very moody. Abusive towards attorneys. Then apologetic. Unpredi...Read More	08/14/2015 12:52 AM	Contact reviewer
19473	Other	No Rating	Not that great of a judge, however, either are most of the Sonoma County Superior Court Judges, with the exception of two or three.	01/06/2013 01:25 PM	Contact reviewer