The Robing Room

Hon. Myra Scott McNaryJudgeCounty CourtPinellas

2.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
64522	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Is very hasty WILLING and WANTS to ship over LAW and FACTS to find what she wants to find and "HELP" people as she thinks are the people she wants to help DO NOT waist your own time effoert to read bring the LAW the facts the con...Read More	01/30/2019 02:59 PM	Contact reviewer
56940	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Im a landlord, and it was like I wasn't there. I believe she had her mind made up before entering courtroom.I had 5 exhibits and she refused to let me present anything. instructions given to Tenant and myself to send any new info ...Read More	06/14/2018 05:21 PM	Contact reviewer
56192	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	I have been before this judge several times as an attorney. I have won some and lost some. I believe a lot of the negative opinions are inaccurate. My only complaint would be that it is difficult to schedule hearings and also di...Read More	05/21/2018 01:19 PM	Contact reviewer
36728	Litigant	No Rating	awful-awful-awful. An embarrassment to the bench, McNary is the worst judge, too lazy to look at the documents, exhibits, and evidence. She is totally uninformed as to the content of the court file and pleadings, oblivious to the...Read More	08/06/2015 01:51 PM	Contact reviewer
35544	Litigant	No Rating	I have been in front of Judge McNary on two occasions. In both cases she clearly had very little regard for the intended purpose of "civil court" being a court for THE PEOPLE, not just for people represented by lawyers. On several...Read More	06/18/2015 08:24 AM	Contact reviewer
35487	Court Staff	No Rating	If there were 0 stars to rate this judge, 0 would be it. Not only is she incompetent -- not even a donor clinic would take her brain -- she has a serious God complex. She is like getting stopped by the rogue police officer peopl...Read More	06/17/2015 10:25 AM	Contact reviewer
30196	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Judge McNary is an embarrassment to the Sixth Judicial Circuit. She has difficulty grasping basic, fundamental principles of law, rules of civil procedure, and rules of evidence. When confronted with a statute or rule that contra...Read More	10/21/2014 04:21 PM	Contact reviewer
23552	Other	No Rating	Judge McNary already had her mind made up when she walked into the courtroom. This was a one-sided case where she gave the defendants 4 months free rent in my rental house. Without knowing all the facts, she completely shut me dow...Read More	10/03/2013 05:45 PM	Contact reviewer
23296	Other	No Rating	Perhaps the reason some find this judge unacceptable is because she uses not only her knowledge of the law but her knowledge of life to aid in her decisions. How can any judge not use both of these in any decision? Unfortunately, ...Read More	09/16/2013 12:56 PM	Contact reviewer
19778	Other	No Rating	Horrible demeanor and attitude. In one case she coached the Plaintiff's attorney on what they needed to file for a successful judgement. How she is allowed to stay seated on that bench is beyond me. Good luck to anyone who gets...Read More	01/29/2013 03:34 PM	Contact reviewer
14391	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	She is just unenlighten. Her demeanor is not judicious. Just lazy and dumb. Easy to confuse her because she does not pay attention. Can rarely find a thread of legal basis in her opinions. Lets others write opinions even when...Read More	04/12/2012 03:29 PM	Contact reviewer
7336	Litigant	No Rating	This judge seemed to already have her mind made up about the case before she heard it from the bench. Her attitude was dismissive and sneering about my presentation of facts. She completely ignored the illegalities committed by t...Read More	08/02/2010 11:40 PM	Contact reviewer