The Robing Room

Hon. Patricia Ann MuscarellaJudgeCircuit CourtPinellas

1.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
114825	Litigant	No Rating	Extremely biased judge. Does not uphold blatant violations of law or the Constitution when indisputable evidence is presented. Sides with foreclosure attorneys every time. If the FDIC confirms "we did not sell this loan to JPM ...Read More	01/23/2023 04:11 PM	Contact reviewer
69679	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	If you get this judge I pray for you. She will side with whoever her friends, Kerry O'Conner and Tina White like. She has violated my civil rights and HIPAA rights, willingly. When she told me to file a motion for a specific issue...Read More	05/28/2019 04:35 PM	Contact reviewer
67964	Litigant	No Rating	This Judge was a life-saver for myself & Special Needs child to obtain protection She should've kept the case in Pinellas b/c after it was transferred to HSFCourt that Judge's annoyance punished us for obtaining an Order of Protec...Read More	04/16/2019 07:08 PM	Contact reviewer
53409	Other	No Rating	Not at all evenhandedness, but dirtyhandiness. I didn't follow my insticts, re:already established bad record and grounds I had to recuse, wanting to think the best. WRONG... What's our electorate got to when you have to base a Ju...Read More	01/06/2018 06:05 AM	Contact reviewer
39830	Litigant	No Rating	This judge is an abomination! Pure anti male bias no matter the evidence presented. I have appeared before her twice for the same issue (restraining order) when I applied I brought police reports, notarized statements and witnesse...Read More	12/29/2015 09:12 PM	Contact reviewer
38979	Litigant	No Rating	Judge Muscarella ignored case law and Florida Statute during a Motion Hearing re: Jurisdiction. Her attitude and snide remarks made me thankful that she actually ruled against me. I'm actually grateful for a Polk County Judge as I...Read More	11/19/2015 08:04 AM	Contact reviewer
37343	Litigant	No Rating	In my opinion; this Judge does not operate within the Florida Civil Rules of Procedure. I am not the only person who has made that observation. Thank you	09/02/2015 01:38 PM	Contact reviewer
33476	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Either she's a complete idiot, or she doesn't read the motions for injunctions that show up before her, and grants them even if nothing warranting an injunction is even ALLEGED.	03/17/2015 01:38 PM	Contact reviewer
31516	Litigant	No Rating	This judge is simply unable to comprehend basic mathematical issues let alone complex transactions. This shortcoming results in totally unequal rulings in divorce FJ. Even when pointed out by both sides I might add you are forced...Read More	12/08/2014 08:47 AM	Contact reviewer
31514	Litigant	No Rating	Inept is the word that springs to mind, along with blatantly biased. Does not understand nor can grasp or follow the law and rules whichever way the wind blows regardless of evidence or proof. Multiple attorneys that we have work...Read More	12/08/2014 08:25 AM	Contact reviewer