The Robing Room

Hon. Mark E. HerrJudgeCounty CourtSeminole

3.4

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
132168	Litigant	No Rating	Arrogant, condescending and completely out of touch. Would rather spend the entire hearing listening to himself talk instead of letting litigants present their case (and evidence). Maybe this is to distract from the fact that he d...Read More	04/08/2025 09:55 AM	Contact reviewer
117077	Other	No Rating	Without a Doubt the most Unruly, Biased, Abusive Judge I have EVER encountered. Herr indisputably, should be removed from the Bench. He is a Detriment to the Judicial Process.	03/30/2023 07:42 PM	Contact reviewer
117057	Other	No Rating	This judge is an advocate against victims rights. While sitting on the bench he openly asked, "when will someone challenge the victims rights act?". He also would moan and exasperate as in pain, "I suppose we need to let the vic...Read More	03/29/2023 10:13 AM	Contact reviewer
117053	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	A Beast. Abusive. Somewhat Knowledgable. Biased. Ruled in favor of lying Defendent with ZERO evidence. Refused to look at Plaintiff’s ACTUAL and PRESEnT evidence. Would have reported Herr for Judicial Misconduct, but he has been ...Read More	03/29/2023 07:37 AM	Contact reviewer
76094	Litigant	No Rating	Mein Herr should be removed from the bench he is a condescending sarcastic moron that calls female defendants by their first name as if they were a/his child. Does not do this with males. Clearly some sort of female sexual harasse...Read More	09/13/2019 07:14 PM	Contact reviewer
57623	Other	No Rating	If your a criminal he is great, if your a victim wishing he holds felons accountable...think again. A felon on community control that scored a 64(over 44 is supposed to be mandatory prison) was brought before him on an out of cou...Read More	07/07/2018 04:16 PM	Contact reviewer
35273	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	the best in seminole county	06/08/2015 08:21 PM	Contact reviewer
6555	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Very good Judge, willing to change his opinions in response to the evidence. Very thoughtful and intelligent	01/04/2010 12:53 PM	Contact reviewer
1196	Civil Litigation - Private	View Details	Judge Herr is evenhanded - he treats everyone terribly. One would think that with the recent disciplining of another Seminole County judge over matters of judicial temperament, Judge Herr would display a more moderate face to the...Read More	12/01/2007 10:41 AM	Contact reviewer