The Robing Room

Hon. Alicia PolkJudgeCircuit CourtPasco

1.0

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
126232	Other	No Rating	This judge is a joke. She is very unfair. She does not like women. It was not ok for me and my children to live with my dad but it was ok for my children to live with their father and his girlfriend of 2 months, if that, at her ...Read More	04/11/2024 06:44 AM	Contact reviewer
126193	Other	No Rating	She is one of the most biased judges I have ever seen.A person should not be able to be a Judge in the same county that they grew up and graduated high school.	04/08/2024 10:46 PM	Contact reviewer
108969	Other	No Rating	From the very beginning of my divorce hearing 7 years in the running Judge Polk has favored my ex wife regardless of how many times my ex was shown to purger herself to the judge she still showed favor to my ex wife with zero con...Read More	07/23/2022 01:06 PM	Contact reviewer
103709	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	returned here simply to add ratings because I overlooked that portion of this site, before hastily adding my comments below	03/25/2022 01:29 AM	Contact reviewer
103708	Other	No Rating	2015: I have NEVER known it to be acceptable behavior for a judge to step down from the bench to console one half of a high-conflict, divorcing couple. Polk offered tissues, placed her arm around, and gave favorable advice to the ...Read More	03/25/2022 01:24 AM	Contact reviewer
102670	Criminal Defense Lawyer	No Rating	I PERSONALLY WILL SAY SHE NEEDS TO BE A HUMAN BEING BEFORE ANYTHING, SHE HAS NO MERCY WHEN IT COMES TO FEMALES NO FEELINGS WHATSOVER MAYBE SHE HAD A BAD RELATIONSHIP WITH A WOMEN AND IS WHY SHE HATES FEMALES OR MAYBE SHE HAD A BAD...Read More	02/05/2022 01:43 PM	Contact reviewer
101196	Other	No Rating	She’s a very biased judge. The lady is very incompetent, does not look at factual evidence, goes by her emotions and feelings (pretty scary). Can you imagine all the mothers and fathers she has ruined because of her proceedings? T...Read More	12/08/2021 08:47 AM	Contact reviewer
78777	Litigant	No Rating	Judge Polk was so incredibly biased in my case I must wonder if my child’s father or one of his representatives somehow persuaded her before hand to rule in the father’s favor.She discounted all of my witnesses as not credible, bu...Read More	11/08/2019 12:59 PM	Contact reviewer
74713	Other	No Rating	I’m surprised to hear men say she is anti-father because our experience has been the opposite. She has not been reasonable in rulings over legitimate concerns, unreasonable with financial decisions, either has a personal dislike f...Read More	08/21/2019 12:25 AM	Contact reviewer
70217	Other	No Rating	...agree that Judge Polk is "anti-father"; seemed cold, indifferent, & biased from the start, almost as if she had a pre-conceived notion that mothers are inherently better caregivers than fathers. If female judges are mothers the...Read More	06/12/2019 12:00 AM	Contact reviewer
69346	Other	No Rating	Biased against fathers getting custody. So men don't waste your money on court because she will not consider anything presented. She just states that the mother has prevailed. She does not address the valid facts presented. She a...Read More	05/22/2019 11:54 PM	Contact reviewer
61174	Other	No Rating	She's amazing and extremely fair. You can tell that she cares of the overall best interest of the children in family law cases. I would consider yourself lucky if you have her as a judge.	11/01/2018 10:14 AM	Contact reviewer
60867	Other	No Rating	Just floored.....thats about all I can think to say at this point.	10/24/2018 07:21 AM	Contact reviewer
56800	Litigant	No Rating	She issued a pick up order for my children; because they did not want to visit their father due to detrimental issues was previously brought to the court attention and she signed an order documenting that; then she vacated that or...Read More	06/10/2018 07:26 PM	Contact reviewer