Hon. Mary C EvansCircuit CourtCollier
2.5
| Comment # | Occupation | Rating | Comments | Date & Time | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 135277 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | Congratulations to the 20th circuit court for clearing a path for justice in regards to future female litigants embroiled in domestic violence litigation. I witnessed Judge Evans exhibit antipathy and hatred in court, resulting i...Read More | 03/01/2026 11:08 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 134981 | Litigant | View Details | Dealing with Judge Mary Evans was a literal nightmare and has destroyed my high need child mentally in so many ways. I, in no way felt I could protect my child or myself in her courtroom. She empowered my ex who is abusive and suf...Read More | 01/22/2026 05:32 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 134935 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | I didn't want to write a review until Judge Evans was no longer on the bench for fear of retribution from this unhinged individual. Ms. Evans was on the bench for 11 years. First in Collier County then in Charlotte County, handli...Read More | 01/16/2026 01:34 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 134642 | Litigant | View Details | I have held back on reviewing this judge at all because I currently have an open case that she is overseeing. However, enough is enough. I have had the misfortune of being in her court room on more than one occasion since 2018. Sh...Read More | 12/03/2025 07:28 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 134338 | Other | View Details | Judge Evan’s allowed me and my son to be abused for 3 years during a ridiculous divorce. She wouldn’t allow any evidence. Evidence that could have prevented my ex husband to now be facing lewd and lascivious child molestation with...Read More | 11/04/2025 12:13 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 132508 | Criminal Defense Lawyer | View Details | An utter Embarrassment to the profession. Should be disbarred and / or removed from the bench. | 05/01/2025 11:39 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 132507 | Litigant | No Rating | This judge is the most unprofessional, rude, obnoxious, embarrassing, and incompetent Judge I've ever experienced. From her personal appearance to personal attacks and bias against women litigants I am appalled at her presence. S...Read More | 05/01/2025 11:37 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 132414 | Other | No Rating | Shocking that this judge has not been reprimanded on her bias behavior. Had two attorneys ask me how attractive my child’s father was because she loves attention from good looking men and more than likely will side with him. Media...Read More | 04/26/2025 03:18 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 132292 | Litigant | No Rating | Without hearing or viewing evidence provided by a woman representing herself during a filing for an injunction for protection for herself and her children, Evans made the dispute a matter of adoption for the four children shared b...Read More | 04/15/2025 11:21 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 129476 | Other | No Rating | This judge ignored legal documentation. All her rulings should be reviewed. She talks about her own marriage and divorce way too much and then compares it to your case. This is not her personal therapy session. She’s biased and fa...Read More | 11/06/2024 09:57 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 128768 | Other | No Rating | Would give 0 if I could. This judge is one of the most incompetent people I’ve seen in a courtroom. Doesn’t even look at the facts in a case. Is beyond petty, and so obviously sexist. You can tell when she *knows* a lawyer. Becaus...Read More | 09/20/2024 03:31 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 127207 | Civil Litigation - Private | No Rating | Went thru a divorce after 30 years of marriage and 4 children. I was asking for alimony as he made about 3x as much as I did and after a bad car accident I had to cut back on working. She denied alimony because she said if I worke...Read More | 06/11/2024 01:01 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 124593 | Litigant | No Rating | First she disgraces the court in Charlotte County. She was shipped out of Collier because of an inappropriate relationship with one of her baliffs.Wish I could give her a 0. Everyone should print a copy of these comments and send ...Read More | 01/04/2024 06:44 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 124592 | Litigant | No Rating | It's an election year and time to flood Gov. Santis with letters about this judge. She is a black mark on the Judicial System. Time to send her down the road. I NEVER thought I would hear a judge say in open court that purgery was...Read More | 01/04/2024 04:05 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 124484 | Other | No Rating | She is normally a family law judge. If you get arrested, hope she is the one covering for the normal 1st appearance Judge. Because of her lack of knowledge she provided the lowest bail on charges for some heinous charged crimes o...Read More | 01/02/2024 12:56 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 124451 | Criminal Defense Lawyer | View Details | Too chummy with counselors. Does not care about the dignity of the court and truth. Unable to put herself in the shoes of others. Especially pro se litigants. Will sell out to the one represented by counsel every time. Owes too ...Read More | 12/30/2023 06:41 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 120689 | Other | No Rating | She deserves to be taken off the bench. Absolutely disturbing behavior in the courtroom. Asks personally offended when the facts are presented to her and she does everything she can to make you sound crazy if you have been through...Read More | 09/21/2023 05:47 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 120505 | Other | No Rating | Judge Evans is a lunatic. From the way she enters her courtroom to addressing the people of the court, or lack there of. She definitely abuses her rights as a Judge and makes biased decisions. She puts children in harms way when t...Read More | 09/12/2023 11:12 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 120470 | Litigant | No Rating | It is clear she is of low level intelligence and refuses to recuse herself when there is clear bias. | 09/09/2023 03:13 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 119860 | Criminal Defense Lawyer | View Details | judge Evans from Charlotte county needs to be removed from her position I had to she overturned my ruling of 90% custody the fact that the mother was involved in several DCF investigations and it dependency case and lied under oat...Read More | 08/08/2023 07:40 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 117763 | Other | No Rating | Biased against mothers. Was supposed to recuse herself because of a conflict of interest. Was asked to recuse herself and she refused. My daughter has regressed so badly due to her decision to not honor the established and notoriz...Read More | 05/03/2023 11:04 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 111812 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | Good judge overall. | 11/15/2022 02:08 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 111269 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | ~This is a family judge that was a practicing family lawyer who not only knows the law but understands the dynamics of a family law case. Because of her experience, she is not going to be fooled by the usual tricks pulled during ...Read More | 10/24/2022 12:17 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 106290 | Other | No Rating | This judge is an embarrassment to family court. She completely ignored important testimony and left my family devastated. She is extremely biased to the father especially if he was absent and then reappears back in the child’s lif...Read More | 07/15/2022 05:10 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 104803 | Other | No Rating | I feel bad for you if you get her ruling your case. She went on vacation two weeks after she heard our case and didn’t even rule. We have been in court for a year now. Still no answers. She definitely doesn’t care about her cases....Read More | 05/10/2022 10:00 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 100636 | Litigant | No Rating | I have been in front mf Judge Evans several times during my divorce and subsequent custody hearings. I hoped and thought she would be fair. She appeared to be so in the divorce hearing, correctly stating that BOTH parties were at ...Read More | 11/17/2021 10:46 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 100418 | Other | No Rating | This woman needs to be off the bench. She doesn't ask important questions and dismisses evidence. Literally just got up and walked away without saying anything at the end. I wasn't allowed to answers the opposite parties questions...Read More | 11/08/2021 11:14 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 78866 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | As a lawyer who has had the chance to sit in on many hearings before Judge Evans, I find her to be fair and patient when it comes to deciding her cases. Judge Evans does her best to follow the law while also reaching the best outc...Read More | 11/13/2019 05:16 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 78864 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | I am a private practitioner and have been appearing before Judge Evans for several years, both in Collier and Charlotte Counties. She is a diligent, prompt, and very able judge, and she works very hard to ensure that the parties r...Read More | 11/13/2019 05:04 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 73257 | Litigant | No Rating | This judge got sent to another county because she was having an affair with her bailiff. She does not have the moral fortitude to be a judge. It is unfortunate she had to leave Collier County because she really fit in with all t...Read More | 07/27/2019 11:47 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 72462 | Litigant | No Rating | none yet no experience, soon I will | 07/13/2019 02:08 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 71565 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | Judge Evans lacks the temperament and general intelligence to be a judge. Couple that with a total lack of legal knowledge creates a disastrous situation for the citizens and attorneys who appear in her courtroom. | 06/28/2019 02:07 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 67989 | Litigant | No Rating | Terrible. Waste of 3 years and thousands upon thousands of dollars. Judge didnt enforce any child support, issued a final judgment with so many errors it took another year for the 4th amended judgment to be issued (still with erro...Read More | 04/17/2019 02:57 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 61292 | Other | No Rating | Judge Evans controls her docket by denying facially sufficient motions and injunctions, only granting hearings on injunctions (instead of issuing temporary injunctions) which puts true victims at more risk, and is incapable of hav...Read More | 11/05/2018 07:28 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 59385 | Litigant | No Rating | Incompetent of having any due diligences, bias, angry on the bench, neglectful of her duties and easily offendered. Not trustworthy. Questionable actions/inactions. | 09/07/2018 06:03 AM | Contact reviewer |
| 54587 | Criminal Defense Lawyer | View Details | One word, "Clueless." | 03/08/2018 02:54 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 53493 | Other | No Rating | Favored attorneys has impaired her Judge of the facts. | 01/10/2018 10:37 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 53492 | Other | No Rating | Easily influence without evidence | 01/10/2018 10:32 PM | Contact reviewer |
| 44765 | Civil Litigation - Private | View Details | This judge appears to have no basic comprehension about what "due process" means. With this judge, we could probably just have her more favored attorney or litigant send in a proposed order and not waste time on the facts of a cas...Read More | 08/15/2016 08:09 AM | Contact reviewer |
© Copyright The Robing Room All Rights Reserved