Logo
Hon. Marcia L. SilvaSuperior Court JudgeSuperior CourtMiddlesex
2.2
Comment # Occupation Rating CommentsDate & Time Actions
72932OtherNo RatingJudge Silva must be terminated immediately. Her ruling is disgusting , appalling. Victimizing the victim while protecting the filthy rapist, she is a DISGRACE!07/20/2019 04:08 PMContact reviewer
72304Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		I highly doubt if she or any relative of hers was sexually assaulted, she would not say there was no damage. She does not belong on the bench.07/11/2019 10:15 AMContact reviewer
72258Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		I love how all of these people come on here and destroy this judge having never appeared before her. They simply believe what they read. I appeared before Judge Silva on several cases, and I find her to be fair and just. She is...Read More07/10/2019 08:45 AMContact reviewer
71930Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		She clearly demonstrates that ALL judges need training on sexual abuse...about the victims, the offenders, trauma, and the myths and stereotypes that are so prevalent in society. These judges are products of that society too. Havi...Read More07/03/2019 10:49 PMContact reviewer
71929OtherNo Ratingshe is a rape apologist07/03/2019 10:46 PMContact reviewer
71899Probation or Pretrial OfficerNo RatingHer IQ is exactly the same as NJ speed limit on surface streets: 35 In mitigation,she is a NY Law School grad. Not NYU, NY Law, a notch up from unacredited correspondence schools.07/03/2019 03:09 PMContact reviewer
71893Prosecutor
View Details		Silva demonstrates a continuous bizarre refusal to follow NJ laws regarding prosecution of teenage rapists.07/03/2019 01:55 PMContact reviewer
71186OtherNo RatingNo harm done to a 12 year old that got rapped? This women is a disgrace. I will hold the rest of my comment I hope there is Karma.06/25/2019 06:07 AMContact reviewer
59809Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		I’ve appeared before her multiple times over the last year and a half and have found her to be fair to both the State and juvenile. She’s always available to conference cases, reasonable with adjournment requests and courteous to ...Read More09/19/2018 07:47 PMContact reviewer
58672Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Most of my experience with NJ state judges has been positive, but it doesn't get worse than this. Will move heaven and earth to get cases off her calendar for no good reason. You can make up court rules and precedent and get away ...Read More08/13/2018 07:55 PMContact reviewer
57069OtherNo RatingThis woman has the intellect of a gnat. Multiple marriages will make you angry at the world. How on earth did she become a judge. She doesn't know the law and the only reason she's there is because she's part of Chris Christie's i...Read More06/19/2018 09:07 AMContact reviewer
56645OtherNo RatingAbsolutely biased against men whether the male is a dad or lawyer. She ignores evidence and isn’t aware of certain parts of the law and as a judge she should be competent enough to know the law in and out. She’s more passionate to...Read More06/06/2018 09:21 AMContact reviewer
54797LitigantNo RatingShe recently presided over my son’s juvenile matter. I was surprised when she said she only been in juvenile for 11 months because she seemed very competent. She was compassionate and patient. She even apologized to our family for...Read More03/21/2018 06:01 PMContact reviewer
53974LitigantNo RatingDoesn't know the law. Needs to be removed from the bench. Biased against DADs. She'll say your a disgruntled parent to hide what she's doing. She lies on the record and in her rulings, ignores evidence and just bitter she's in a l...Read More02/04/2018 08:56 AMContact reviewer
49238OtherNo Ratingrefuse to follow case laws and her oath as a lawyer and judge. Lies on the record. If you're a male and minority she thinks you subscribe to MACHISMO so watch out. Constantly violates fathers rights because her pension is tied to ...Read More05/01/2017 02:51 AMContact reviewer
48543OtherNo RatingI always thought a judge would have to look at All the evidence presented to her. I guess our Court system has changed this judge rules on what she thinks she believes to be right. I Want to say shame on Gov Christie for appoint...Read More03/29/2017 02:02 PMContact reviewer
46643LitigantNo RatingI found her to be caring and compassionate. She listened to both parties, cut through the bs easily and made a fair ruling. She tries to settle matters often but when that doesn't work she will make a ruling.12/07/2016 08:01 PMContact reviewer
45426LitigantNo RatingHorrible human being. Former prosecutors shouldn't be in family court. Lies on and off the record. Her staff says nothing for a paycheck. Angry woman who's life is in shambles so she's taking it out on any man that comes thru. If ...Read More09/17/2016 08:36 PMContact reviewer
36836LitigantNo RatingI was blindsided by my ex when in court for another issue and was smacked with an order to show cause before walking in the courtroom. He had a lawyer since he knew what he was planning to do to me and I did not, as I was not prep...Read More08/11/2015 10:00 AMContact reviewer
31638LitigantNo RatingFair and kind. I am a man and was surprised by her ruling. I have been brutalized in Middlesex county family court for 4 years. Silva was the first judge to rule in the best interests of my child. Lord Bless Judge Silva and I pray...Read More12/13/2014 11:22 AMContact reviewer
28611OtherNo RatingSexist, biased, does not know the law she is suppose to enforce. Will not enforce prior court orders (including her own). Cannot handle complex issues. If you are a man going before her, keep it at an elementary school level.08/05/2014 09:33 PMContact reviewer

© Copyright The Robing Room All Rights Reserved