Logo
Hon. Peter J. MelchionneSuperior Court JudgeSuperior CourtBergen
2.0
Comment # Occupation Rating CommentsDate & Time Actions
123756LitigantNo RatingRedacted by Ed. Doesnt want to do his job and be a judge. I simply wanted to keep a parenting plan that my ex wife and i had followed for 4 years. Ex wife, who was investigated by CPS 3 times and involuntarily sent to a loony ...Read More11/19/2023 05:04 PMContact reviewer
114695OtherNo RatingExtremely unfair. A misogynist who does not care about children or the impact that domestic violence has on our society or families that suffer from this. What a sorry situation to have him in this role.01/20/2023 09:40 AMContact reviewer
111807LitigantNo RatingMelchionne destroyed my life. DO YOU FEEL LIKE YOU WERE RAILROADED/INVALIDATED BY NJ BERGEN COUNTY FAMILY COURT???  Do you want the justice that we/us/our children deserved?  This may sound vague. However, this is our chance for ...Read More11/15/2022 12:12 PMContact reviewer
103052LitigantNo RatingWhat is going on that Bergen Court judges are causing more chaos, more harm, and more injustice than if they never got involved in the first place? They are a complete menace to families and to society.02/21/2022 07:27 AMContact reviewer
69969LitigantNo RatingObese ,incompetent slob, the epitome of how judges are given the job, an incompetent, unsuccessful lawyer who needs a job, makes political contributions for two years and gets a no show job as a judge. No wonder 80% of lawyers don...Read More06/04/2019 03:20 PMContact reviewer
60318Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Never seen such a cruel, bad judge hurt people and children like Bergen County Chief Division of Families Peter J. Melchionne. Women leave his court shaking and trembling not to recover for months or years or ever. Children's l...Read More10/05/2018 11:12 PMContact reviewer
52128OtherNo Ratingthe Judge is bias. unfit to even be called a judge and to be over others. his irrationality is beyond belief. his judgement calls are not right at all.10/12/2017 08:39 PMContact reviewer
51964Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Worst rotten excuse for a sadistic ruthless barbarous fiend in the world today. God help us all and all the children and families tortured, destroyed and killed by this monster until this evil Satan Mephistopheles is sent back to ...Read More10/02/2017 09:54 PMContact reviewer
50373LitigantNo RatingMelchionne is extremely inhuman. When presenting evidence that my children have been abused and were suffering from bruising after being taken by DYFS, Mellchionne said it was Ok for them to be in the custody of people abusing my ...Read More06/29/2017 03:18 PMContact reviewer
48165LitigantNo RatingPathetic. Didn't read anything. Facts were so clear and had to slowly repeat things to him. It was the end of the day and he must have been tired and didn't have his usual nap in the afternoon. When I called him pathetic at th...Read More03/09/2017 09:40 PMContact reviewer
42901LitigantNo RatingWhat a terrible judge who cannot make a decision. He should definitely be removed from the bench. He is also a major misogynist.05/23/2016 11:20 AMContact reviewer
36934OtherNo RatingThis guy is incompetent . He does not know laws and regulations. He does not read the documents provided to him. He does not accept the reports from state licensed doctors. He does not look at the evidences. He is an absolute moro...Read More08/16/2015 09:44 PMContact reviewer
35874LitigantNo RatingHe is very fair.....He doesnt buy into the lies and crocodile tears of lying woman. That can only be the reason he gets any bad reviews. He actually does his job and sees the truth.06/30/2015 12:42 PMContact reviewer
28117Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Best experience ever. Truly honorable with amazing abilities to handle complex matters. Hagit Levinson07/16/2014 11:01 AMContact reviewer
28115Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		Bias Judge and protect the abuser not the true victim.07/16/2014 09:58 AMContact reviewer
24557OtherNo RatingThis judge should be removed from the bench. He is a biased individual who doesn't care about what a mother has to go through in order to protect her children. He applauds deadbeat fathers and continues to allow them to get away w...Read More12/11/2013 08:44 AMContact reviewer
19575LitigantNo RatingA one star rating is too generous for judge Melchionne.01/14/2013 01:13 PMContact reviewer
16540Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		This Judge is corrupted and completely out his mind! This judge needs to be removed from the bench now before he does anymore damage!08/02/2012 09:33 PMContact reviewer
15843Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Should be removed from the bench. Completely bias. It is a shame this man represents our legal system. Though no legal system is perfect, it would be a good start to can judges like him before they do to much damage.07/02/2012 12:55 PMContact reviewer
15401LitigantNo RatingAnother attorney called this man a "Rogue Judge". He does not seem to bother to fully read motions or pleadings and clearly dsiregards case law and fact. He makes up the rules as he goes along. I am amazed that no one seems to pay...Read More06/10/2012 10:13 AMContact reviewer
14978Civil Litigation - Private
View Details		Absolutely shocking. It is unbelievable such a judge has been there. Constantly smiles and winks at counsel he sides with. Sits quietly giggling while he fabricates outrageous decisions based on any allegation he hears simply t...Read More05/19/2012 09:22 AMContact reviewer
13995LitigantNo RatingThis man has caused me to have no faith in our justice system. Complete narcoses, bias, Corrupt and should be removed from the court. Smiles and winks at female council that he sides with. Interesting! Makes up numbers and conveni...Read More03/13/2012 05:03 PMContact reviewer
10603Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		This judge absolutely missed the mark. He allowed a child to lose all visitation with his loving and capable father because of uncorroborated stories from the mother, who has a history of mental illness. She also extorted money ...Read More04/27/2011 05:30 PMContact reviewer
6790Criminal Defense Lawyer
View Details		An excellent Judge and an example to all. Its a shame that other Judges in Bergen County do not follow Judge Melchionne's lead.03/12/2010 01:56 PMContact reviewer

© Copyright The Robing Room All Rights Reserved