The Robing Room

Hon. Kathleen J. PrendergastJudgeCommon PleasYork

1.3

Comment #	Occupation	Rating	Comments	Date & Time	Actions
135054	Other	View Details	A normal judge would have thrown out the petty barking dog case. Kathleen Prendergast is not a normal judge: 1. She consistently sides with police and prosecutors, regardless of any constitutional constraints, with zero regard f...Read More	01/31/2026 07:47 AM	Contact reviewer
132257	Litigant	No Rating	[Redacted by Ed.] she suppressed an unconsitutionally obtained a warrantless DUI blood test and turned around and let the equally corrupt DA prosecute it with no other evidence at a bench trial. Naturally found me guilty of a gen...Read More	04/13/2025 07:41 PM	Contact reviewer
120200	Litigant	No Rating	So this judge is very passive aggressive, especially if you don't have a lawyer. She would ask me a question and when I tried to answer she would interrupt and shout me down. Then when I would try to finish my answer she has her s...Read More	08/26/2023 06:46 PM	Contact reviewer
120199	Litigant	No Rating	So this judge is very passive aggressive, especially if you don't have a lawyer. She would ask me a question and when I tried to answer she would interrupt and shout me down. Then when I would try to finish my answer she has her s...Read More	08/26/2023 06:45 PM	Contact reviewer
117448	Litigant	No Rating	` This judge makes up her mind before you come into court and if you try to advocate for yourself she takes it personally and makes it 10x worse. Her credibility determinations defy credibility and she's very quick to assail yours...Read More	04/18/2023 04:17 PM	Contact reviewer
116723	Criminal Defense Lawyer	View Details	Comments: This judge is abusive comes into the court with a formed opinion you have no chance at justice. She wants power and control,she will fine your thousands of dollars if you challenge her.She fabricates testimony and inject...Read More	03/13/2023 05:17 PM	Contact reviewer