Hon. Robert L. Jackson (Payette)
Judge Jackson is bias against women and children. Doesn't abide by best interest laws or child's wishes. Denied a protection order with substantiated evidence of second degree burns on a child. Criminally charged a mother for protecting a child against a man charged w strangulation and assault. Didn't allow evidence of second degree burns or allow mother to defend child. Rewarded a child abuser with more time and took protective parents time away against the child's wishes. Awarded abuser w special times and days that wasn't allowed for other parent. Forcing protective parent to pay abusers attorney bill. Was promised child support, Jackson denied that as well. Jackson did not protect this child. Criminally charged a mother with ridiculous over charges when mom had no prior offenses or any trouble w law ever. Idaho statutes clearly say a parent had the right to keep the child away from harm and Jackson didn't adhere to that law either. Child abuser only charged w disturbing the capeace for second degree burns, while mother got 2 years supervised probation a week of work crew and a $2000 fine, threatened w jail time for protecting my son because this judge refused to protect a child from a child abuser and women abusers, father has extensive history of domestic violence and Jackson Didn't consider any of this as evidence. Showed clear bias, legal abuse. Jackson needs investigation into how he handles child abuse as I see he has no experience in this field so why is he a family court judge??? He blatantly did not follow laws of Idaho on abuse.
Criminal Defense Lawyer
- (
3/9/2025 5:27:50 PM
)
Hon. Jennifer Haemmerle (Blaine)
This judge is so horribly biased, and has not shown ANY equalityy in court proceeding with my family for the past 2 years. She talks in circles and repeats herself incessantly. She should not be a judge, since she is incapable of being objective or balanced. She is heavily swayed by her bias.
Other
- (
2/5/2025 7:07:55 PM
)
Hon. Robert James Caldwell (Kootenai)
Caldwell presided over a case in which I was defendant. He was fair and professional. I would say the same thing whether I won or lost the case.
Other
- (
10/25/2024 3:47:29 PM
)
Hon. Clark A. Peterson (Kootenai)
It's hard to believe there are no ratings on this guy. He has been in the news quite a bit, and all of the news is bad. He has spent hours each workday playing online video games. Has shown himself partial in his judgments (favors attractive female plaintiffs or defendants). Has behaved disrespectfully to others in court. [Redacted by Ed.] Was reprimanded by the Idaho judicial authority. https://judicialcouncil.idaho.gov/pdf/press/2023-19&20-Peterson-Public-Reprimand-2023-11-30.pdf Is now restricted in the types of cases he is allowed to handle.
Other
- (
10/25/2024 3:43:15 PM
)
Hon. Cynthia Meyer (Kootenai)
This judge presided over the case between North Idaho College vs. Nick Swayne. Swayne was chosen as NIC president by an UNelected board of trustees, appointed by the Idaho State Board of Education bureaucracy, through a plot hatched by local Leftist elitists. Later, the ELECTED board wanted to do its duty in representing the people by investigating Swayne's appointment as president. Swayne sued. This judge characterized the elected board's action as "arbitrary and hostile". [Redacted by Ed.]
Other
- (
10/25/2024 3:31:04 PM
)
Hon. Robert C. Naftz (Bannock)
Judge Naftz is extremely lazy, biased and runs a unjust court. Idahoans watch out. He will violate a citizen's civil rights by the application of silly court rules, which should be applied to allow parties to be heard and receive a fair hearing over litigious matters. If it means work he finds ways to apply rules to deny one's rights. VOTE HIM OUT!
Other
- (
6/22/2024 12:21:53 AM
)
Hon. Robert C. Naftz (Bannock)
Judge Naftz [Redacted by Ed.] Uses court rules to deny access to be heard. He also knew I was not formally served through ICourt,violating my 5th and admendment rights to a fair hearing and still ordered a default judgment against me removing me as trustee. Judge Naftz is lazy and is not interesting performing the work of a Judge. He should be removed from the bench. When I walked into the court room it was evident he was biased and against me. One should be made to feel the Judge is a neutral party. Beware Pocatello, Sixth dDistrict Judge Naftz must go! I suggest voting him out come next elections.
Other
- (
6/3/2024 10:32:34 PM
)
Hon. Theodore Tollefson (Ada)
This guy is not a friend of fathers, a parent should judge a parent! It’s called being equally yoked. This guy laughs with my ex wife during a hearing. That was a terrifying sound. I’m watching this guy closely, I haven’t seen my kids in over two years, and I’m pissed. I’ve never abused my kids nor their mom, and I do not use drugs or abuse alcohol.
Other
- (
1/6/2024 11:05:32 PM
)
Hon. Joanne Kibodeaux (Ada)
Incompetent If she is binding cases over to district court she better know the law! You can’t maintain a grand theft charge against a spouse if they live in the same abode. Her incompetence cost me ten grand hiring retaining an attorney that knew the law.
Other
- (
1/6/2024 10:56:47 PM
)
Hon. Jason D. Scott (Ada)
If you’re a defendant or their counsel watch out! We heard prior to our hearing from other attorneys this man is a friend of the state. Long story this judge allowed the state to admit a recording that my wife took of me into the trial. We argued that the statue that codified spousal privilege controlled, because the issue is a substantive right. He ruled the issue was procedural so the rule controlled. [Redacted by Ed.] the prosecutor McDevitt walked up to us before the hearing all cocky, after submitting the most lazy argument ever, and started asking my attorney about his golf swing. Watch out if you have this dude handling your case! He has 125+ cases go to the appellate court since 2014.. that’s a lot of disagreement.
Other
- (
1/6/2024 10:51:13 PM
)