| Name | Title | Vicinage | County | Rate this Judge | Rating | # of Ratings |
| Hon. Gregg Padovano | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 2 | Bergen |  | | 0 |
| Hon. James Paganelli | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 5 | Essex | | | 1 |
| Hon. Phillip Lewis Paley | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 8 | Middlesex | | 4.1 | 13 |
| Hon. James Palmer, Jr. | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 3 | Burlington | | | 0 |
| Hon. James Palmer, Jr. | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 14 | Ocean | | | 3 |
| Hon. Joseph Paone | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 8 | Middlesex | | | 1 |
| Hon. Anthony Parrillo | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 7 | Mercer | | | 0 |
| Hon. Mitchell Pascual | Judge | Vicinage 6 | Hudson | | | 0 |
| Hon. Russell Passamano | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 5 | Essex | | 2.3 | 6 |
| Hon. Anne Murray Patterson | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 10 | Morris | | | 0 |
| Hon. Edith Payne | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 5 | Essex | | | 0 |
| Hon. Stuart Peim | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 12 | Union | | 10.0 | 2 |
| Hon. Darlene Pereksta | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 7 | Mercer | | 2.9 | 5 |
| Hon. Joseph Perfilio | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 12 | Union | | | 0 |
| Hon. Michelle Perry-Thompson | Judge | Vicinage 1 | Atlantic | | | 0 |
| Hon. John Peterson, Jr. | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 14 | Ocean | | 6.0 | 11 |
| Hon. Stephen Petrillo | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 5 | Essex | | 4.7 | 9 |
| Hon. Michael Petrolle | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 5 | Essex | | | 0 |
| Hon. Anthony Picheca, Jr. | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 13 | Somerset | | 8.8 | 6 |
| Hon. James H. Pickering, Jr. | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 1 | Cape May | | | 1 |
| Hon. Diane Pincus | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 8 | Middlesex | | | 2 |
| Hon. John Pisansky | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 12 | Union | | 1.0 | 4 |
| Hon. Sheree Pitchford | Judge | Vicinage 8 | Middlesex | | | 0 |
| Hon. Benjamin Podolnick | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 1 | Atlantic | | | 2 |
| Hon. Steven Polansky | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 4 | Camden | | | 1 |
| Hon. Robert Polifroni | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 2 | Bergen | | 10.0 | 3 |
| Hon. Laurie Poppe | Judge | Vicinage 14 | Ocean | | | 2 |
| Hon. Paul Porreca | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 15 | Gloucester | | | 0 |
| Hon. Joseph Portelli | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 11 | Passaic | | | 2 |
| Hon. John Porto | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 1 | Cape May | | 1.0 | 1 |
| Hon. Gary Potters | Judge | Vicinage 6 | Hudson | | | 0 |
| Hon. Charles Powers, Jr. | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 2 | Bergen | | 1.8 | 2 |
| Hon. Anthony Pugliese | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 4 | Camden | | 1.6 | 16 |
| Hon. Lorraine Pullen | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 8 | Middlesex | | 3.3 | 4 |
| Hon. John Pursel | Superior Court Judge | Vicinage 13 | Warren | | 6.9 | 2 |
| Hon. Kevin Purvin | Judge | Vicinage 2 | Bergen | | | 0 |